To Drink or Not to Drink? Exploring the Consequences of Interacting with Thisobald Thorm in Baldur’s Gate 3

In Baldur’s Gate 3, players encounter Thisobald Thorm, the son of Ketheric Thorm, in Act 2 within the cursed village. The decision to share a drink with Thisobald can lead to various outcomes, and players are often torn between avoiding conflict and reaping potential rewards. Here’s a guide to help you navigate the choices with Thisobald Thorm, filled with cautionary spoilers.
What Happens if You Drink With Thisobald Thorm?
Drinking with Thisobald Thorm is a delicate dance with consequences. If players agree to indulge him, they face challenging checks, requiring either genuine alcohol consumption or adept deceit. Choosing a character with a high Sleight of Hand stat, like Astarion, can help avoid consuming alcohol. Alternatively, embracing the drink leads to Constitution checks, crucial for coherent storytelling. Failure due to inebriation may hinder the ability to share vital information with Thisobald.

What if Players Fight Thisobald Thorm?
Refusing to drink or attempting to deceive Thisobald triggers an immediate battle. This proves challenging, given his robust health and immunity to physical attacks. Hostile ghouls join the fray, attacking the party. While defeating Thisobald yields rewards, including a key for a hidden room behind the bar containing weapons and a recipe for Purple Worm Poison, the effort may not be justified.
Best Choice
Opting to drink with Thisobald, passing checks, and avoiding combat unveils valuable information about Ketheric Thorm’s secret relic. Additionally, the ghouls remain peaceful, ensuring the party receives the full XP at the conversation’s end. An unexpected reward awaits as Thisobald, in his intoxicated state, literally explodes, providing a key for further rewards. Choosing diplomacy over confrontation emerges as the superior path for players in this intriguing encounter.